Portrait Pro Forums
Testing the Waters - Printable Version

+- Portrait Pro Forums (https://forum.portraitprofessional.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://forum.portraitprofessional.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Forum: Photo critique (https://forum.portraitprofessional.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=8)
+--- Thread: Testing the Waters (/showthread.php?tid=3048)

Testing the Waters - lalareid2202 - 03-06-2012

A Self Port...Critique plz!
1st SOOC [attachment=477]
2nd Edit [attachment=478]

RE: Testing the Waters - ctconger@gmail.com - 04-30-2012

You are a very pretty girl. Try a little less skin smoothing.

RE: Testing the Waters - david5512 - 06-12-2012

(03-06-2012, 06:20 PM)lalareid2202 Wrote: A Self Port...Critique plz!
1st SOOC
2nd Edit

I agree with the other posting. You need very little work. I'd tone it down since just a slight touch up would be stunning. I've been working with one woman whose face needs a great deal of work and in her case, you have to go heavy. Your bone structure and lack of blemishes is outstanding.

RE: Testing the Waters - john garrett - 06-12-2012

(03-06-2012, 06:20 PM)lalareid2202 Wrote: A Self Port...Critique plz!
1st SOOC
2nd Edit
you appear to have mastered it on this oneRolleyes
john garrett

RE: Testing the Waters - gwlaw99 - 10-11-2012

It looks like you focused a little above her eyes so her eyes are not tack sharp. Her mouth and chin look out of focus.

RE: Testing the Waters - PaintedRays - 02-18-2013

I agree with all said earlier. A little texture in the skin is necessary.

RE: Testing the Waters - randomAccess - 02-20-2013

Well, late to the party and the OP is no doubt long gone, but:
- selfies are hard... I ought to know! Especially focus. Choosing about f/4.0 (for a normal distance, say 6' with about an 85mm lens for this shot) and letting the camera face-priority auto-focus in liveview (nikon terms) will give better results. Here, only one eye is in focus - both should be. The rest of the face / image is an artistic choice depending on usage.
- the lighting appears to largely on-camera (notice the centred catchlight in the eyes). Get it off-camera for depth! Which can be done at home without umbrellas by bouncing off the ceiling and using a 4x6 white card on the flash for fill (or ambient for fill, or a large white card propped-up near the subject for fill). Give or take. The subject (the OP) is pretty, one could do butterfly lighting easily, or maybe broad lighting too.
- the image is under-exposed about one stop. The Red channel never gets past about 220, and it should be 236-241 in the highlights (forehead over eye, and right cheek).
- the crop is really, really tight, making the head look quite large. Unless there is some reason to crop this way, I think pulling back and including more hair and neck would help.
- head /eye angle is good for a 2/3 view. Shoulder angle is good - neckline is likely too deep, but with this crop and the light intensity dropoff, no problem. Teeth are good. Expression is pretty good considering it is a self-portrait. I think the background colour works with the subject, but would prefer a more-neutral colour, or an opposing colour (blue / green tone)
- too-heavy retouch. even magazine covers leave more texture... as others have noted. I find the default PP settings too aggressive.